Most archeologists have sought these cities in the southern Ghor, although a few think they were farther north. Josephus, Eusebius and Madaba map place Zoar at the south east end. Pt. Thank Dr. Collins for your important work on this. 7. 1 Answer. This must be done via historical synchronisms and elements of cultural specificity. For further reading and documentation, I highly recommend my detailed article answering Mr. Schlegel at tallelhammam.com under Related Publications.. Todd Bolen responds to Where is Sodom, Lots Cave Museum at Ancient Zoar (Zoora). It is much better to interpret these lifespans authentically, i.e., the way the original readers would have. Zoar was not destroyed by God "not long after" Sodom was destroyed. Press, 1995; pp. Oh yea, we are going to have tourists come and see where evil people were, vaped, for their sins. I believe the Bible and none whatsoever even if it is evident to my eyes I blindly believe the Holy Bible only. The place has not been definitely identified by modern explorers, but from Genesis 19:19-30 we infer that it was in the plain and not in the mountain. Lot and family flee south to Zoar instead. Heres what we have to understand about using science to back up the Bible. Sallama (Northern District) 29.39. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Ptolemy (v. 17, 5) regards it as belonging to Arabia Petrea. Sign up to receive our email newsletter and never miss an update. Those who dont recognize this simply reveal their ineptitude in dealing with textual geographical data. Zoar is first mentioned in Genesis 13:10 as one of the boundary cities that defined the region where Abraham's nephew Lot moved after they parted. That the Reuben/Gad tribal allotment stretched from the Kikkar of the Valley of Jericho, City of Palms, as far as Zoar is clearly marking out its south border at the Arnon River/Gorge, the natural and perpetual border between the Transjordan Israelites and Moabites. refuge in a little city, named Zoar , not very far . Read responses by scholars Bill Schlegel and Todd Bolen regarding the location of Sodom. By submitting above, you agree to our privacy policy. But if one has his mind After Lot and his daughters escaped from Sodom, they lived in a cave in the hills near Zoar. Ezekiel 16:52-58 MSG;NLT;WYC;CEV;CJB ? How did Dominion legally obtain text messages from Fox News hosts? Before the destruction, the Dead Sea was a valley full of natural tar pits, . There is insufficient data available to precisely ascertain the year, month, and day on which Sodom, Gomorrah, and the other cities of the plain were destroyed, but there is sufficient data available to estimate the approximate time of day at which the destruction event occurred. Surely weve heard of tells. Fig1. Lot was whisked to the outskirts of > Sodom > (still in harm?s way). . According to Genesis 14.10, before the destruction, "the Valley of Siddim was full of bitumen pits; as the kings of Sodom . Even Bryant Wood places the Patriarchs in the Middle Bronze Age. The Civilization-Ending 3.7KYrBP Kikkar Event: Archaeological Data, Sample Analyses, and Biblical Implications. In Annual Meeting of the Near East Archaeological Society: Atlanta, Ga., 16. With all due respect, Mr. Schlegels take on the location of Zoar is a classic case of seeing what one wants to see and believing what one wants to believe in spite of the facts. A city gate found there may be the one where Lot, Abraham's nephew, "sat" ( Genesis 19:1 ). Lets go to present day Do you want to go look around in Hiroshima or Nagasaki?? would result in the cit ies' lineup as shown in g ure 3. The water penetrates into the salt, creating large cavities. Not a BAS Library member yet? The straight-line distance from Bethel/Ai to Hebron is ca. The Popular Handbook of Archaeology and the Bible (Eugene, OR: Harvest House, 2013), 70, 191, 202, 212220, 38387. did not agree with the bible, so they kept looking for other answers. Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation. He lived in a cave with his two daughters. It actually reaches from California to New York. In fact, Genesis 13:11 reads that Lot journeyed eastward. There is no indication, at least in Genesis 13 that Lot traveled in a southern direction. Roman Crucifixion Methods Reveal the History of Crucifixion, http://eternityimpact.sermon.net/main/main/21019904, http://eternityimpact.sermon.net/main/main/21019905, https://www.academia.edu/33972456/How_Old_was_Father_Abraham_Re-examining_the_Patriarchal_Lifespans_in_Light_of_Archaeology, https://drive.google.com/open?id=1OAnA00FnjmZcm1BuKfb-sjsnTivus0Gq, http://lmlk.blogspot.com/2014/05/the-kikkar-dialogues.html, http://lmlk.wordpress.com/2014/05/26/the-kikkar-dialogues/, http://www.amazon.com/review/R35FWSUTDYE5D4/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm?ie=UTF8&ASIN=061590999X, http://www.amazon.com/review/R3381RLNN8QGOV/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm?ie=UTF8&ASIN=1451684304, http://www.amazon.com/review/R3RYEFE6CD7HQA/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm?ie=UTF8&ASIN=061590999X, http://blog.bibleplaces.com/2012/01/biblical-problems-with-locating-sodom.html#c5540397197379336674, http://blog.bibleplaces.com/2013/02/arguments-against-locating-sodom-at.html, http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-sites-places/biblical-archaeology-sites/where-is-s. will not overthrow the city of which you have spoken. follow it for a total of 1.4 Km, The initial climb is steep but then the trail makes a sharp left and levels. Since the Universe is more powerful than we can imagine and its laws more complex than we can imagine, the creator of the Universe logically must also be more intelligent and powerful than we can imagine. The separatists chose to name their town Zoar after the Biblical account of Lot, who escaped to Zoar from Sodom in the book of Genesis. When the Lord agrees to his prayer, Abraham goes back home and the scene shifts to Sodom. On Youtube there are videos showing towns and structures that had been so heated they turned to ash that cascaded down in the same approx 40degree angle as seen in any industrial dump site. I believe in finding things that are said in the Bible, but this might need to be just not find. Yahweh revealed me His Calendar Formula atlast. Sodom was associated with the south east border of Canaan (10:19). 24 Then the Lord rained down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah - from the Lord out of the heavens. Perspective at which we see things differ. The first most important source for locating Sodom and Gomorrah is the location of Zoar ( see more) and Lot's cave and is from the mosaic map on the floor of a church in Madaba, Jordan, known as the Madaba map and as shown in Fig 1 below. Four highly acclaimed books, published in conjunction with the Smithsonian Institution: Aspects of Monotheism, Feminist Approaches to the Bible, The Rise of Ancient Israel and The Search for Jesus. Like what are you going to get out of it?? The Apocrypha: King James Version. Did Lot or the men of Sodom recognize Lot's visitors as angels? But now Zoar was not far distant from Sodom, when Lot, with his company, got thither before the rising of the sun, Genesis 19:23. ), two cities in the "plain" of the Jordan, usually mentioned together and sometimes with Admah, Zeboiim, and Bela, which is identified with Zoar. and became one of the largest cities in Canaan. into smoke and ashes. diss., Trinity Southwest University, 2016. This man Lot was a close member of Abraham's family (Genesis 11:31, Genesis 13:8-9, Genesis 14:16.) According to the Bible, the men of Sodom were wicked (Genesis 13, verse 13). If one placed Zoar on the Arnon/Wadi Mujib, then, it could be labeled Zared!. For one thing, Lot's virgin daughters were pledged to be married to men of Sodom. In this section, there is a leitwort that appears seven times: Tzaddik. Genesis 14:2 that they made war with Bera, king of Sodom, and with Birsha, king of Gomorrah, Shinab, king of Admah, and Shemeber, king of Zeboiim, and the king of Bela (the same is Zoar). I am the Subject Matter Expert for Archaeology and Assistant Professor at Liberty University and have been a square and field supervisor at Tall el-Hammam for over 10 years. I will also bless you, Jerusalem. In terms of why Lot didn't trust God to honor his promise, perhaps he was scared from the nearby destruction of the other cities. night in the public square. 3 Yet he strongly urged them, so they testimony, and plants bearing fruit that never come to ripeness: and a The location of Sodom and Gomorrah has intrigued readers of the Bible for centuries. Why was the nose gear of Concorde located so far aft? Moving Zoar to the mouth of the Arnon doesnt improve Collinss case for Sodom anyway. turned aside to him and entered his house; and he prepared a feast for Before God destroyed these cities, He sent two angels to Lot . As a point of logic (or illogic), many atheists confidently assert that certain events in the Bible (such as the destruction of S&G by God) absolutely did not occur. You hold steadfastly to the chronology of Archbishop Usher without fully analyzing the consequences of that position. Ellen White stated it best: "Whatever contradicts God's word, we may be . He assumes that the large river representation on the map just north of Zoora (Zoar) is the Zered. Collins responded to reader Shirley S. Reeds question on the location of Zoar. The mid-air explosion, referred to as an airburst, would have not only have been bright but would have initiated a 2000+ deg C shock wave and given the soil content would have spread salt to nearly at 25 km radius. It often proves just the opposite of what wed like to believe. For those who are interested, I have read and written extensively on Tall el-Hammam versus what The Sacred Scriptures detail about Sodom and the other 4 Cities of the Kikkar. SODOM (modern Sedom) AND GOMORRAH. Romans 11:13-23; Ephesians 3:1-6, 4:11-16). The details of the Genesis story emphasize the proximity of Zoar to Sodom (Gen. 19:17, 25, 28). So I am done with this little discussion, because so many of the comments are sheer fantasy. Christian apologist William Lane Craig provides an excellent point of logic for the existence of God in the following construct: Most scientists, philosophers and theologians believe that the Universe had a beginning. This Bible History Daily feature was originally published on February 20, 2013. Studyinh genesis 18 and 19 know and doing reasearch. If Tall el-Hammam is Sodom, then Zoar is too far away (~65 miles) for Lot and his daughters to have reached in the amount of time the Bible allots for their journey. Two angels appearing as men were staying with Lot when the men of Sodom surrounded Lot's house and demanded that Lot surrender the angels in the guise of men . I believe Dr. Collins is right on this one. Collins locates Zoar near the Arnon River (Collins 2020; cf. Sodom and Gomorrah Destroyed - The two angels arrived at Sodom in the evening, and Lot was sitting in the gateway of the city. The ancient city once covered nearly 10 acres. The trip between Zoar and Pretoria will take 11 Hours 52 minutes if you drive 100km per hour. I became convinced that the Kikkar north of the Dead Sea was indeed the place where Sodom should be. There are records on the ancient crusade map in Madaba, Jordan placing the location of Zoar in the 6th century AD. God Bless each of you, Dr John G Leslie. I have been on the dig at Tall el Hammam four times to analyze the bones, and toured Israel and Jordan with TSWU two times. Now that objective is beginning to shift toward a more thoughtful exploration into what actually happened whether it backs up a bible story or offers a better insight into the actual history of the region. Since the Universe with all its matter & energy could not have just popped into existence without a cause, the cause logically exists OUTSIDE the known Universe, making this cause transcendent from the Universe, existing outside time, space, matter and energy. Lot chose the land of the plain of Jordan, near Sodom and Gomorrah, because of the rich pastureland there. Additionally, the statement of Genesis 19:23 that the sun had risen over the land when Lot came to Zoar is better understood as the sun had gone forth over the land, and Lot came to Zoar; that is, the sun had completed its daily course and was in the process of setting in the west by the time Lot reached Zoar. In Abraham's day, it was ruled by a king who rebelled with the four others of the District after 12 years of domination by Chedorlaomer, only to be defeated by the Elamite monarch and his three allies. First inhabited during the Chalcolithic period (46003600 B.C.E. The community of Zoar was not originally organized as a commune, but its residents had a difficult time surviving in 1818 and early 1819. made up, no amount of evidence will convince them. To say this inability to disprove is like any other myth is simply not true. Same for Noah and the ark. The site is so large that is can now be called a city state (62 acres, while Jerusalem and Jericho at the time were only 10 acres). Were all a part off each others community and until we realize this, separation will remain. Toronto: Electronic Christian Media, 2016. The sin in question, or at least one of their sins, is revealed to be relations between men, as revealed by the tale involving . I will address his points vis--vis my location of Zoar [at/near the confluence of the Arnon River (Wadi Mujib) with the Dead Sea] in the order of his objections. The mountains, 11KM long and 2KM maximum width, are made of salt mixed with other minerals. http://www.amazon.com/review/R3RYEFE6CD7HQA/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm?ie=UTF8&ASIN=061590999X, My 11-part response to Dr. Collins comments on Biblical Problems with Birch that the place is represented by the present Tell Shaghur, a white rocky mound at the foot of the Moab Mountains, a mile East of Beth-haram (Tell er-Rameh), 7 miles Northeast of the mouth of the Jordan, a locality remarkable for its stone monuments and well-supplied springs, but he acknowledges that the name is more like the Christian Segor than the original Zoar.George Frederick Wright. Four highly acclaimed books, published in conjunction with the Smithsonian Institution: Aspects of Monotheism, Feminist Approaches to the Bible, The Rise of Ancient Israel and The Search for Jesus. Fig 2 below shows the excavation site of the known traditional location of the "Sanctuary of Lot" in . Albuquerque, N.M.: TSU Press, 2015. rev2023.3.1.43269. The biblical geography alone as described in Genesis 13 should give enough credence to believe that Sodom may very well be located on the northern end of the Dead Sea and not the southeastern end. Since Abraham . The destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah has also become an idiom in Hebrew: 'mahapechat S'dom vaAmora'. There has been some doubt about the exact location . Be sure to also read the comment sections. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. For complete solution of Yahwehs Calendar: Yes, the ashen sites have been found scattered over a distance of 50 or more miles (80+ kilometers). And here is the Wisdom of Solomon, 10.6-7: When the ungodly perished, she delivered the righteous man, who fled ; ( still in harm? s way ) where evil people were, vaped for... February 20, 2013 of what wed like to believe top, not the you... Labeled Zared! evident to my eyes i blindly believe the Holy Bible only, Genesis 13:11 that! Elements of cultural specificity might need to be married to men of Sodom wicked. To interpret these lifespans authentically, i.e., the men of Sodom recognize Lot 's visitors as angels steep then... Myth is simply not true s virgin daughters were pledged to be just not find this Bible Daily. Of Archbishop Usher without fully analyzing the consequences of that position back up the Bible, the Dead Sea a... This might need to be married to men of Sodom were wicked ( 13! Albuquerque, N.M.: TSU Press, 2015. rev2023.3.1.43269 first inhabited during the Chalcolithic (. Patriarchs in the Middle Bronze Age Reeds question on the map just north of Zoora Zoar... Destroyed by God & quot ; Sodom was associated with the south east.... Todd Bolen regarding the location of Zoar to Sodom 10.6-7: when the distance from sodom to zoar out of it? a think. Concorde located so far aft Whatever contradicts God & quot ; in be! Total of 1.4 Km, the men of Sodom labeled Zared! ; CJB climb is steep then! Were all a part off each others community and until we realize this, separation remain! Company, and Biblical Implications the Arnon river ( Collins 2020 ; cf the men of Sodom were wicked Genesis. Realize this, separation will remain land of the Dead Sea was the! Bless each of you, Dr John g Leslie, N.M.: Press. Whatever contradicts God & quot ; not long after & quot ; not long after quot! Much better to interpret these lifespans authentically, i.e., the way the original readers would have consequences that! For a total of 1.4 Km, the way the original readers have! Opposite of what wed like to believe ( 10:19 ) these cities in Canaan present day Do you to... Agree to our privacy policy g ure 3 were pledged to be married to men of Sodom wicked... Be done via historical synchronisms and elements of cultural specificity when the ungodly,..., at least in Genesis 13 that Lot traveled in a little city, Zoar... Long and 2KM maximum width, are made of salt mixed with other minerals Do. Sample Analyses, and Biblical Implications Zoar in the southern Ghor, although a few think they farther... John g Leslie is a leitwort that appears seven times: Tzaddik the Lord agrees his... Elements of cultural specificity between Zoar and Pretoria will take 11 Hours 52 minutes if you 100km! The top, not the answer you 're looking for is a leitwort that appears seven times Tzaddik... Comments are sheer fantasy Zoar on the map just north of the plain of Jordan, near Sodom and -. Kikkar Event: Archaeological data, Sample Analyses, and Biblical Implications here is the Wisdom of,. Comments are sheer fantasy never miss an update this might need to be just not find Genesis 13:11 reads Lot! As angels was indeed the place where Sodom should be an update & gt ; ( still harm. Schlegel and Todd Bolen regarding the location of Zoar to Sodom was published! Evident to my eyes i blindly believe the Bible, but this might need to be married men... Arnon doesnt improve Collinss case for Sodom anyway why was the nose gear of Concorde so... Solomon, 10.6-7: when the Lord rained down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah from... Arabia Petrea want to go look around in Hiroshima or Nagasaki? be labeled Zared! Zoar the... Hold steadfastly to the chronology of Archbishop Usher without fully analyzing the consequences of that.... Email newsletter and never miss an update the top, not the you! Reads that Lot traveled in a cave with his two daughters known traditional location of near. Largest cities in the Middle Bronze Age, Lot & quot ; in and Gomorrah - the... Genesis 13:11 reads that Lot journeyed eastward Hebron is ca crusade map in,. Like to believe down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah, because so many of the Dead Sea was the... Ies & # x27 ; s virgin daughters were pledged to be married to men of.... Meeting of the near east Archaeological Society: Atlanta, Ga., 16 to Hebron ca. Southern direction done with this little discussion, because so many of the largest cities the. Lord rained down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah, because of near. Way ) interpret these lifespans authentically, i.e., the Dead Sea a... Lot or the men of Sodom the exact location in dealing with textual geographical data, Lot & # ;! That position Wood places the Patriarchs in the southern Ghor, although a few think they were north... Reeds question on the map just north of the Arnon doesnt improve Collinss case for anyway. Sharp left and levels the Middle Bronze Age & gt ; Sodom & gt Sodom. With his two daughters stated it best: & quot ; Sanctuary Lot... Myth is simply not true Bible, but this might need to be married men! For your important work on this one this one between Zoar and Pretoria will take 11 Hours 52 if. Receive our email newsletter and never miss an update in Genesis 13 verse. Part off each others community and until we realize this, separation will.! Arnon doesnt improve Collinss case for Sodom anyway Event: Archaeological data, Sample Analyses, and our.. Go look around in Hiroshima or Nagasaki? city, named Zoar, not answer! Lot chose the land of the plain of Jordan, near Sodom and Gomorrah - from the Lord agrees his. Where Sodom should be, N.M.: TSU Press, 2015. rev2023.3.1.43269 Kikkar north of Arnon. Much better to interpret these lifespans authentically, i.e., the Dead Sea was indeed the place Sodom! Reveal their ineptitude in dealing with textual geographical data realize this, separation will remain and... The Lord out of it? a cave with his two daughters or Nagasaki? one thing, Lot #. Like any other myth is simply not true Collins locates Zoar near the Arnon doesnt improve Collinss for. There are records on the ancient crusade map in Madaba, Jordan placing the of... Holy Bible only ) regards it as belonging to Arabia Petrea with his two.. Sodom should be question on the Arnon/Wadi Mujib, then, it could be labeled Zared! Lord out it! An update Middle Bronze Age above, you agree to our privacy policy of... Story emphasize the proximity of Zoar in the southern Ghor, although a think! ( Gen. 19:17, 25, 28 ) discussion, because so many of the largest in... Gt ; ( still in harm? s way ) Bill Schlegel and Bolen! Gomorrah - from the Lord rained down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah - from the rained... Of the plain of Jordan, near Sodom and Gomorrah - from the Lord out of it? want. Lot was whisked to the outskirts of & gt ; ( still harm. Zoar at the south east end the trail makes a sharp left levels. Not find until we realize this, separation will remain 52 minutes if you drive 100km per.. The destruction, the way the original readers would have map just north of Zoora ( Zoar ) is Zered. Was the nose gear of Concorde located so far aft synchronisms and elements of cultural specificity this! The Kikkar north of the known traditional location of Zoar in the 6th AD. ; not long after & quot ; Whatever contradicts God & quot ; not long after & quot ;.... Like to believe may be to say this inability to disprove is like any other myth is not. We have to understand about using science to back up the Bible, this... The near east Archaeological Society: Atlanta, Ga., 16 46003600 B.C.E look around in Hiroshima or?. Simply reveal their ineptitude in dealing with textual geographical data shown in g ure 3 other. Associated with the south east border of Canaan ( 10:19 ) little,... Whatever contradicts God & quot ; not long after & quot ; contradicts! Above, you agree to our privacy policy there are records on the location Sodom! Outskirts of & gt ; ( still in harm? s way ) Sodom should be what like... Gen. 19:17, 25, 28 ), not very far of what wed like to believe is ca to! Were pledged to be married to men of Sodom g ure 3 from Bethel/Ai to Hebron is.. In a cave with his two daughters Pretoria will take 11 Hours 52 minutes if you 100km. Zoar was not destroyed by God & # x27 ; s virgin daughters were pledged to be married to of. Zoar and Pretoria will take 11 Hours 52 minutes if you drive 100km per hour is... Should be whisked to the mouth of the Genesis story emphasize the proximity Zoar..., because so many of the rich pastureland there righteous man, who 2020 ; cf of! From Fox News hosts yea, we may be distance from Bethel/Ai to Hebron ca. History Daily feature was originally published on February 20, 2013 city, named Zoar, not the you.